Skip to content
archdiff

models / compare / inkling-vs-minimax-m3

Inkling vs MiniMax-M3

How Inkling (Thinking Machines Lab, July 2026) and MiniMax-M3 (MiniMax, June 2026) are built, drawn on the same November 2026 blueprint. They make different choices on 10 of 27 components. Select a component in either diagram to find it in the table.

--- frontier-llm@2026-11+++ inkling@2026-07+0~5−3

Inkling

Thinking Machines Lab, July 2026, 975B total, 41B active

Text · code · tool outputText · code · tool outputImages · video · audioImages · video · audioByte-level BPE tokenizer — 128K–262K vocabByte-level BPE tokenizer128K–262K vocabVision / audio encoder — native ViT or encoder-free patchesVision / audio encodernative ViT or encoder-free patchesToken embedding — media embeds spliced in placeToken embeddingmedia embeds spliced in placeEngram n-gram memory — hashed 2–4-gram lookup (V4.1)Engram n-gram memoryhashed 2–4-gram lookup (V4.1)Single pre-norm residual stream — Residual & normSingle pre-norm residual streamResidual & normRMSNorm — pre-normRMSNormpre-normQK-Norm — per-head RMSNorm on q, kQK-Normper-head RMSNorm on q, kLearned relative-position bias (no RoPE) — AttentionLearned relative-position bias (no RoP…AttentionGated DeltaNet / KDA — linear · ~3 of every 4 layersGated DeltaNet / KDAlinear · ~3 of every 4 layersGlobal GQA with log-length scaling — AttentionGlobal GQA with log-length s…AttentionSparse / compressed attn — DSA indexer · CSA / HCASparse / compressed attnDSA indexer · CSA / HCASliding-window attention — local · 128–1,024-token windowSliding-window attentionlocal · 128–1,024-token windowShort causal convolutions (SConv) — AttentionShort causal convolutions (SConv)Attention⊕ residual⊕residualRMSNorm — pre-normRMSNormpre-normSigmoid router with shared-expert sink — Mixture of expertsSigmoid router with shared-expert sinkMixture of expertsRouted experts — top-6–22 of 256–896 · SwiGLURouted expertstop-6–22 of 256–896 · SwiGLUShared expert — 1–2 · always activeShared expert1–2 · always active⊕ residual⊕residualFinal RMSNormFinal RMSNormLM head — untied · vocab logitsLM headuntied · vocab logitsMTP module(s) — predict t+2 … t+kMTP module(s)predict t+2 … t+kNext-token logitsNext-token logitsDraft tokensDraft tokensMuon optimizer — Newton–Schulz · QK-Clip · per-headMuon optimizerNewton–Schulz · QK-Clip · per-headFP8 → FP4 training — block-scaled FP8 · MXFP4/NVFP4 QATFP8 → FP4 trainingblock-scaled FP8 · MXFP4/NVFP4 QATLong-context extension — staged 4K → 1M · YaRNLong-context extensionstaged 4K → 1M · YaRNRL with verifiable rewards — GRPO family · async agentic RLRL with verifiable rewardsGRPO family · async agentic RLOn-policy distillation — reverse KL to specialist teachersOn-policy distillationreverse KL to specialist teachersSpeculative decoding — MTP self-drafting · DSparkSpeculative decodingMTP self-drafting · DSparkKV-cache compression — FP4 KV · cross-layer reuse · SSDKV-cache compressionFP4 KV · cross-layer reuse · SSD
AttentionMixture of expertsResidual & normInput & outputTraining & inferenceData flowResidual / skipAddedReplacedNot usedNot disclosed

--- frontier-llm@2026-11+++ minimax-m3@2026-06+0~4−4

MiniMax-M3

MiniMax, June 2026, 427.0B total, 23.5B active

Text · code · tool outputText · code · tool outputImages · video · audioImages · video · audioByte-level BPE tokenizer — 128K–262K vocabByte-level BPE tokenizer128K–262K vocabVision / audio encoder — native ViT or encoder-free patchesVision / audio encodernative ViT or encoder-free patchesToken embedding — media embeds spliced in placeToken embeddingmedia embeds spliced in placeEngram n-gram memory — hashed 2–4-gram lookup (V4.1)Engram n-gram memoryhashed 2–4-gram lookup (V4.1)Single residual stream — Residual & normSingle residual streamResidual & normRMSNorm — pre-normRMSNormpre-normQK-Norm — per-head RMSNorm on q, kQK-Normper-head RMSNorm on q, kPartial RoPE / NoPE — rotate 64 dims, or nonePartial RoPE / NoPErotate 64 dims, or noneGated DeltaNet / KDA — linear · ~3 of every 4 layersGated DeltaNet / KDAlinear · ~3 of every 4 layersFull grouped-query attention in blocks 0–2 — AttentionFull grouped-query attention…AttentionMiniMax Sparse Attention (MSA) — AttentionMiniMax Sparse Attention (MS…AttentionSliding-window attention — local · 128–1,024-token windowSliding-window attentionlocal · 128–1,024-token windowOutput gate + sink — σ(x·W_g) ⊙ o · learnable sinkOutput gate + sinkσ(x·W_g) ⊙ o · learnable sink⊕ residual⊕residualRMSNorm — pre-normRMSNormpre-normMoE router — σ / √softplus · bias balancingMoE routerσ / √softplus · bias balancingRouted experts — top-6–22 of 256–896 · SwiGLURouted expertstop-6–22 of 256–896 · SwiGLUShared expert — 1–2 · always activeShared expert1–2 · always active⊕ residual⊕residualFinal RMSNormFinal RMSNormLM head — untied · vocab logitsLM headuntied · vocab logitsMTP module(s) — predict t+2 … t+kMTP module(s)predict t+2 … t+kNext-token logitsNext-token logitsDraft tokensDraft tokensMuon optimizer — Newton–Schulz · QK-Clip · per-headMuon optimizerNewton–Schulz · QK-Clip · per-headBF16 weights plus an official MXFP8 checkpoint — Training & inferenceBF16 weights plus an official MXFP8 ch…Training & inferenceLong-context extension — staged 4K → 1M · YaRNLong-context extensionstaged 4K → 1M · YaRNRL with verifiable rewards — GRPO family · async agentic RLRL with verifiable rewardsGRPO family · async agentic RLOn-policy distillation — reverse KL to specialist teachersOn-policy distillationreverse KL to specialist teachersSpeculative decoding — MTP self-drafting · DSparkSpeculative decodingMTP self-drafting · DSparkKV-cache compression — FP4 KV · cross-layer reuse · SSDKV-cache compressionFP4 KV · cross-layer reuse · SSD
AttentionMixture of expertsResidual & normInput & outputTraining & inferenceData flowResidual / skipAddedReplacedNot usedNot disclosed

Component by component

Inkling and MiniMax-M3 differ on 10 of 27 components.

Blueprint componentInklingMiniMax-M3

Single pre-norm residual streamOne d = 6,144 residual stream through 66 pre-norm blocks; no hyper-connections, branch outputs pass a short conv.

Single residual streamOne d = 6,144 residual stream with pre-norm sublayers; no hyper-connections.

Learned relative-position bias (no RoPE)Each head adds a bias by backward distance: a query-dependent mix of 16 learned profiles, over 512 (local) or 1,024 (global) tokens.

Same as the blueprintPartial RoPE in all 60 layers, unchanged from M2: the first 64 of each head's 128 dims rotate (rotate-half layout) and the other 64 carry no position, with base θ = 5,000,000. The indexer's queries and key are rotated the same way. The config allows 1,048,576 positions with no YaRN or other scaling.

Global GQA with log-length scaling11 full-attention layers (every 6th, incl. the last): 64 Q / 8 KV heads, d_h = 128; logits scaled up logarithmically past 128K.

Full grouped-query attention in blocks 0–2The first three blocks attend over the whole context: 64 query heads share 4 KV heads of dim 128; no indexer, gate or sink.

Not used

MiniMax Sparse Attention (MSA)Per GQA group, a 2-projection indexer picks the top 16 of 128-token KV blocks; exact softmax over ≤ 2,048 keys, in 57 of 60 layers.

Same as the blueprint55 of 66 layers (all except 5, 11, …, 65) attend to the last 512 tokens with 64 query heads and 16 KV heads of dimension 128. Keys and values pass through a kernel-4 causal convolution before caching, and the relative-position bias spans the whole window.

Not used

Short causal convolutions (SConv)Depthwise causal convs (kernel 4, with skip) on K, V and on both sublayer outputs before they rejoin the residual.

Not used

Sigmoid router with shared-expert sinkScores 256 routed + 2 shared experts; bias-steered top-6; weights normalized jointly over the 8 active experts, then ×8.

Same as the blueprintAn FP32 linear router scores 128 experts with sigmoids. A per-expert bias (e_score_correction_bias, FP32) is added only to choose the top 4, the 4 unbiased scores are renormalized to sum to 1, and the routed output is multiplied by 2.0 (routed_scaling_factor) before the shared expert is added. MiniMax has not described how M3's biases are updated or whether an auxiliary balance loss is used.

Same as the blueprintMuon for large matrix weights and Adam for all other parameters, with weight decay coupled to the square of the learning rate. Hyperparameter schedules draw on Thinking Machines' modular-manifolds research. Newton–Schulz settings are not published.

Not disclosed

Same as the blueprintTraining precision is not published. Weights ship in BF16 and as an NVFP4 checkpoint (W4A4, 16-element blocks with E4M3 scales) that quantizes only the routed experts of MoE layers 3–65. Attention, shared experts, routers, dense MLPs, the first MoE layer's experts, embeddings, head, norms and convolutions stay BF16, and the KV cache is not quantized. Whether NVFP4 was trained in (QAT) is not stated.

BF16 weights plus an official MXFP8 checkpointBF16 release with an FP32 router; MiniMax-M3-MXFP8 stores the text stack's linears as E4M3 with one 8-bit scale per 32 weights.

Same as the blueprintThe 8 MTP layers act as drafters for speculative decoding, verified by the full model so outputs match plain decoding. Thinking Machines has not published acceptance rates.

Not disclosed

More comparisons